Pentagon: Identification of Human Remains

Passengers got onto flight AA77 at Dulles Airport on the morning of 9/11/2001. Those asserting that something other than AA77 hit the Pentagon must deal with the question, what happened to the passengers? The identification of human remains of passengers in the Pentagon is one path to establishing that AA77 is actually what hit the Pentagon. It is therefore worthwhile to study the process of collection and identification of the remains and the documentation of that process.

Some initial skepticism of government handling of the body parts is understandable, given the precedent of the notoriously fraudulent autopsy of John F. Kennedy, where doctors with no autopsy experience involving gunshot wounds were brought in to do the autopsy under the direct control of a number of high ranking military officers who micromanaged and falsified the process. This was a clumsy coverup which resulted in multiple whistleblowers who testified to the irregularities. [JFK and the Unspeakable by James W. Douglas]

However, there have been no such irregularities reported in the case of the Pentagon victim identification project. Unlike the case of JFK, where there was one victim and two pathologists under the direct control of several high ranking military officers, the Pentagon victim identification project was massive, involved many scientific and medical personnel with relevant expertise, and was systematic and well organized, with no reports of interference. Elizabeth Woodworth, 9/11 researcher, assistant to David Ray Griffin, and co-founder of the 9/11 Consensus Panel, is a retired medical librarian with experience in the field of documentation of scientific work. She has documented the competence and credibility of the medical examiners leading the project. Some have estimated as many as 1000 people were involved overall, many with direct emotional ties to the victims. It is not plausible that they were all on the “inside” of a plot to falsify the findings.

Bodies and body parts were located and documented in the Pentagon itself, each fragment being tagged and photographed. (One might wish to obtain these photographs, but that would be an uphill battle, given the privacy rights involved.) Many were reduced to small parts that could not be identified by eye. Dogs were used to assist in finding small fragments. When the identification process was exhausted inside the building, tons of debris were moved to the North Parking area where it was systematically sifted. Every movement of remains, or potential remains, involved documentation of the chain of custody. In the end, there were 189 fatalities, including 59 passengers and crew of AA77, 125 Pentagon personnel, and 5 five presumed hijackers. All but 1 of the passengers and all but 4 of the Pentagon personnel, were identified through forensic methods. The presumed hijackers were victims without comparison DNA and with Middle Eastern origin, two of whom were brothers.

Elizabeth Woodworth has written a short summary of the reasons to consider the identification process to be valid based on her research and experience. One of the documents she cites is a paper by the lead medical examiner, Andrew M. Baker, MD, that describes the identification process in detail. He writes,

“All of the human remains– of which there were more than 2000 separate specimens– were moved to the U.S. Air Force Port Mortuary at Dover AFB, Delaware, for evaluation. There, a multidisciplinary team of pathologists, dentists, anthropologists, fingerprint specialists, radiologists, DNA technologists, photographers, morticians, and support personnel used a systematic, stepwise approach to ensure that every scientifically available method was utilized to maximize the number of victims that could be positively identified, reassociated, and returned to the families.”
[Human Identification in a Post-9/11 World: Attack on American Airlines Flight 77 and the Pentagon Identification and Pathology]

Another document, compiled from hundreds of oral history interviews, by a team of historians for the Historical Office of the Department of Defense, is Pentagon 9/11 which attempts to provide a comprehensive overview of the work during the aftermath of the disaster. In particular, see
Chapter 5 — Treating the Injured, Searching for Remains, and
Chapter 8 — Caring for the Dead and the Living

A database of victim body parts keyed to their location in the building was compiled with an interactive graphical user interface accessible as a Windows program called pentagon-scene.exe and entered into evidence in the Zacarias Moussaoui trial. A zip file containing this program is available here.

Note the buttons along the bottom, that go to additional pages with second and third floor data and a list of victims identified in the sifting operation in the North parking area. When running the program, there are a number of significant regularities that can be observed.

  • The black ovals, representing unknown DNA of Middle eastern origin, presumably the hijackers, are found near the entrance hole. This is consistent with their being in the cockpit which would be the first part of the plane to disintegrate.
  • When one oval is highlighted, all other ovals representing fragments from the same person are also highlighted. It is notable that these tend to be distributed along the flight path, consistent with the breakup of the plane, rather than being radially distributed, which might indicate distribution by an explosion.
  • A large number of body fragments were swept through the C-ring exit hole. This is consistent with the hole resulting from the wall being bombarded with plane fragments from the inside flowing outward along the flight path, rather than the wall being breached by explosives after the event as some have speculated.
  • The flight data recorder, and the unreadable cockpit voice recorder, were found near the C-Ring exit hole, which is consistent with their location in the tail section of the plane, which would be some of the last parts of the plane to be destroyed in the impact. Think of the distribution of plane debris being an approximate inverted image of the plane itself.

Personal effects found with the bodies were returned to the families. Besides providing emotional closure this constituted an additional layer of confirmation of the identifications.

Comments are closed.